I agree with you and with Todd about 80% on sticking with the Wing-T. I've mentioned before, I do think that should be the base offense for FH and for Alco, especially when our kids face down state teams with more speed and athletic talent. But I think it limits our programs as well.... mostly against each other, but that's an argument for a different day.
It's not that an in-house guy couldn't bring some new looks to FH (or Alco), but am I right in saying that any current in-house FH candidates didn't play football in college? I don't know the whole staff, only a few of them, so I could be wrong. Also, to clarify two main points about a coaches resume in regard to college playing experience:
- On one hand, there's no question you learn things at that level that would help as far as leadership, talent evaluation, scheme, fundamentals, etc. that could benefit a high school program. Having someone with that experience could help with that 80/20 of Wing-T as the base and then having some other wrinkles to throw in. I gave an example last Fall of how we ran a spread in college, which was completely foreign to me, but we still ran a really effective single and double-pull trap/counter combo out of a 4-wide set. It's simple math - less guys in the box means less guys to block.
- On the other hand, it's absolutely not a requirement that a head coach played in college to have success. Coach Appel and Coach Kane didn't play in college, and they both had successful runs. On the flip, our current head coach played D2 and we've really been struggling for a couple years now, so I realize the other side of my point as well.
I also noted for the FH guys sometime last year (I think) that I figured this was coming for two reasons: Candy has a rep for being a semi-militant, no-nonsense gal who's not a FH insider. And the other reason was a perfect storm of being the FH head coach isn't an easy gig regardless of success, combined with Appel being his own worst enemy at times. Those three elements combined, in my opinion, are what resulted in Appel resigning. And it wasn't really a surprise.